@Purplefowler is also looking for that rocking horse shit that is 'the cherry' i believe. I figure it's going to come down to mixing several cherry flavours
I've pretty much stopped diy these days but I never did find a good cherry. I'd give my right tit to know what magic @PlumeBlu used to make his cherry juice because after a good steep, his cherry juice is very good (just got up and can't remember it's name, sorry!).