INW Shisha Vanilla is good, it's a very 'typical' vanilla taste to me.
FA's Madagascar and Vanilla Bourborn are both very solid vanillas too.
.. and TPA's French Vanilla Deluxe.
Those 4 are my favs and the only ones I really use these days.
I think i may have some TPA's French Vanilla Deluxe in my stash
INW Shisha Vanilla with some caramel should do it. I at least get A LOT of caramel from Holy Vanilla. I dont get much vanilla though.