There's a trade off for against Silicone, Nitrile & Viton O-rings, Viton & Nitrile are harder materials compared to Silicon so they are more robust and less susceptible to wear and tare (Viton I believe is the hardest of all three), but being harder has its downfalls, where O-rings are used on top caps or AF control rings Viton & Nitrile will give a much tighter fit and a lot more bite/grip. Silicone being a softer material will provide a better seal as it will form/shape better against each mating surface, but being softer its more susceptible to wear and tare. All three materials are suitable for temperature and suitable for PG/VG.
If it was me, and I was 100% certain on the size needed, I'd go for the cheaper, softer Silicone and buy plenty of spares to replace whenever needed.
Edit: I've bought O-rings from here before and have most sizes and materials (hint if you want Silicone, enter it in the search, for some reason they're not listed in the menu's.
https://simplybearings.co.uk/shop/