He initially specified that he wanted to mix it at 10-15% and later clarified he was aiming for 2mg/ml, and as 10% and 2mg/ml is within spec I reckon he's got it right...
Your tastes, or my tastes, are utterly irrelevant to be honest - I'd be mixing it at 1-2% for myself and 15% for the wife, but what bearing does that have on what anyone else likes?